When it comes to the Internet, people do a lot of
things they would never do in real life. They look at porn which they
never would dream of purchasing at a store for fear of embarrassment.
They pretend to be different people in chat rooms and on discussion
boards, and hide behind an online "persona" (or three). They say
things they would never dream of saying to another man's face.
And sadly, they also feel free
to steal.
Why do people do all these things
online? Because it is easy to
do! But while it is certainly easier to steal
another man's text and images rather than to create your own, It
is also 100% Illegal.
The Internet is legally considered a "published work". That means
that any articles, pictures, etc. that are placed online are
protected for their author, just as if they were in a physical volume
in your hands. To steal a story from a web site is just as illegal as
if you were to steal it from a recent novel. This applies even if the
author does not say it is copy written. Protection is automatically
granted when it is published electronically. The university I used to
work at had to deal with these issues all the time. A professor could
not just go and print out someone's site for use in a class anymore
than they could just copy someone's textbook for the class. These
kinds of issues are considered very serious in both the academic and
legal world!
Now, this does not mean you can't link to an article on someone's
site. Links are "fair use" because you are not claiming the image or
written idea as your own. You are only pointing the way to a good
thing you found, hoping others will enjoy it as well. Links are
great!
This does not mean you can't print out a copy of something for
private use, either. If it is going to go into your paper files for
you to refer to in training, that is one thing, and no one is going
to bother you. If you decide to start to selling these copies,
however, you then are in violation of the law. These can be complex
issues, and we are all lucky that so many web sites, organizations,
and libraries have decided to host electronic books despite these
problems!
What I am referring to in this article is straight out theft. People
just taking text, JPEGS or GIFS from one site and putting them on
another without permission. This happens more often than you think,
and just recently it happened to us here at Alliance. I am not
talking about one picture being stolen, either, but 28 GIFs
constituting an entire period training manual!
Now, we have always been open to giving out a lot of information on
this site. Spreading the Western Martial Arts is our mission, and I
have personally spent thousands of hours writing articles, scanning
pictures, and generally working my butt off to expand this site with
fresh, relevant content...and all for free. For someone to just go
and steal my work (ie. my time, sweat and effort) is a breach of the
most basic level of decency and respect.
It shows they just do not care that I work on this site when I might
rather be doing something else, like working on my house, playing
with my dog, or spending time with my wife. No, to these kinds of
jerks it doesn't matter, they just want something cool for
their site and figure they won't get caught so "Yo-ho-ho" and
away they steal with a simple "right-click save as".
There are ways to prevent this, but I never thought it necessary to
do. I can create my images so they can not be copied, but it
is a pain in the butt to do. Frankly, I'll just stop putting up free
books on the site before I'll waste my time doing that. Why should I
spend the hours in this chair banging away on the site if people with
no respect for me are just going to come and try to steal what they
can, eh?
In this recent case, an entire book that I scanned for the
American Heritage Fighting Arts Association was stolen and put up on
another site. They have since taken the images down at our request,
and have told us that these 28 scans were given to them by people
from the "University of Nevada
European Fighting Club". We have been unable
to find any record of this club.
If anyone out there has ever
heard of, or had contact with, the "University of Nevada European
Fighting Club" please do contact us!
When people have asked us to use certain images, we have
usually granted permission. Recently a fellow wrote to ask if he
could even use a whole training manual for his site...and after
hearing he wanted to translate it into Russian, we agreed! This is
the right way to do things, folks, with some respect. He didn't want
a handout, he wanted help in scholarly work. He wanted to share
something with a whole new audience, and put his own time in. That is
the way! Ask - Don't Steal!